老九品茶

Skip to main content

Equal performance, unequal pay: Why women's teams fall behind

Women's soccer team

Women teams can win championships, draw huge audiences and rival men on the field. But according to new research, women teams are often judged differently and rewarded less than comparable all-male teams despite producing the same results.

The research suggests the gap isn鈥檛 just about popularity or revenue. In a series of studies spanning sports, healthcare and workplace settings, researchers found that all-women teams are often evaluated differently and paid less even when their performance matches men.

Mallory Decker

Mallory Decker

鈥淭he gender pay gap is compounded by who women work with. When women work exclusively with other women, they鈥檙e judged differently than men who work with men,鈥 said听Mallory Decker, a PhD student at the听Leeds School of Business and lead author of the study, published in February 2026 in .

鈥淲hat different here is that it happening at the group level,鈥 said听David Hekman, associate professor of organizational leadership and information analytics at Leeds and co-author of the study. 鈥淏ut once you get into teams鈥攕ports, music, venture capital鈥攖hat where the gap really shows up.鈥

The research began with a simple question: Why have pay gaps narrowed for some individual athletes and entertainers but stayed so wide for teams?

鈥淭here been a lot of attention on the gap between men and women pay in sports, especially team sports,鈥 Decker said. 鈥淵ou see individual women doing incredibly well鈥擲erena Williams, Naomi Osaka鈥攂ut that gap hasn鈥檛 closed in team settings.鈥

Using data from more than 900 international sporting events听across 44 sports鈥攆rom soccer and tennis to surfing鈥攕panning 2014 to 2021, along with salary data from healthcare organizations and a series of experiments,听Decker and Hekman found a consistent pattern: Men tend to benefit financially from working together, while women working in all鈥憌omen groups often do not. In those events, men competing in groups earned more than twice as much as women in comparable group competitions. Meanwhile, pay for individual events was far closer, with much smaller gaps between what men and women earned.

David Hekman

David Hekman

Performance doesn鈥檛 explain the gap in team pay. In the study, men and women teams produced identical results, but people consistently rated all鈥憌omen teams as more likely to challenge the status quo and as deserving less pay, while all鈥憁en teams were seen as more legitimate.

鈥淲hen men work with other men, it supports norms people are used to,鈥 Decker said. 鈥淭hey seem more dominant, more competent鈥攁nd that what we tend to value.鈥

鈥淭hat not true for women,鈥 she added. 鈥淲hen women work together, it can feel outside the norm, and people are more likely to react to it as something disruptive.鈥

Those reactions are often subconscious, Hekman said.

鈥淎 group of women can be perceived as听threatening because it looks like they could change existing social hierarchies,鈥 he said. 鈥淎nd in our study, those perceptions were linked to lower pay.鈥

That same pattern shows up beyond sports, the study found. All鈥憌omen groups are largely absent from the highest鈥慻rossing music tours, reflecting a broader trend the researchers also observed in workplaces like healthcare.

鈥淚t not that women can鈥檛 succeed,鈥 Hekman said. 鈥淭hey absolutely do as solo performers. It that when women work in groups, they鈥檙e basically not even on the scale.鈥

Decker said that bias isn鈥檛 usually intentional.

鈥淚 don鈥檛 think people are consciously thinking, 鈥楲et pay women less for equal work,鈥欌 she said. 鈥淏ut everything in our experiments was the same except for gender鈥攁nd people still rated women as deserving less pay.鈥

That study findings have implications for workplaces trying to close pay gaps, Decker added.

鈥淩ight now, organizations tend to look at pay equity one person at a time鈥攕ame job, same tenure, same skill level,鈥 she said. 鈥淏ut at the group level, that gap actually gets bigger. Who you鈥檙e working with matters.鈥

For Hekman, the takeaway raises a broader question. 鈥淚f we like teams鈥攁nd we clearly do,鈥 he said, 鈥渨hy do we only seem to value them when they鈥檙e men?鈥